High StreetSeneca

Open now

Call(740) 685-5954

Open today

Hot subs, a real deli counter, and whatever you forgot.

The general store on South High Street. Sandwiches made to order at the Seneca Subs counter, two miles from Seneca Lake.

Call the store Get directions
  • 5.0 on Google
  • Open 7 days
  • 2 mi from the lake
"Beautiful clean deli with lots of fresh meat and cheese options. Hot Subs are Amazing."
Erica Cummins, Google review
The High Street Seneca storefront on South High Street in Senecaville, Ohio 166 S High St · Senecaville

5.0 stars on Google

From their Google listing. Read the reviews

Seneca Subs

The sub counter

Seneca Subs is the counter inside the store. Subs and sandwiches, made to order.

Today's menu and prices

The full list with prices is going up here shortly. Until then the counter will tell you what is on today. We would rather leave it blank than print a price that has changed.

Call (740) 685-5954

In the store

What regulars mention most, taken from their own Google reviews.

Honey on the shelf at High Street Seneca
Honey
Kettle corn on the shelf
Kettle corn
Hershey's ice cream freezer
Ice cream
Cheesecakes in the case
Sweets
Candles on the shelf
Candles
Wax melts on the shelf
Wax melts
A grocery aisle inside the store
Groceries
The deli case
The deli case

Stock changes. If you are making a trip for something in particular, call first.

What the neighbors say

★★★★★

"The new owners have brought a fresh, friendly vibe to the store. Beautiful clean deli with lots of fresh meat and cheese options. Hot Subs are Amazing. My grandkids love to get the Hershey's ice cream!"
Erica Cummins July 2025

★★★★★

"The place has completely turned around with the new owners. They took something good in Senecaville and made it great. The subs are my absolute favorite. It's a quick and easy stop when your on the way to Seneca Lake."
Courtney Seeley July 2025

★★★★★

"The girls in the back are so funny and helpful. You guys have great staff. Love the jerky options!"
Kate McDowell March 2026

Been in? Leave a review

Heading to Seneca Lake?

The store sits about two miles west of Seneca Lake Park, on South High Street in Senecaville. Stop on the way in rather than driving back out to Cambridge for the thing you forgot.

31328557428556631377SENECAVILLESENECALAKE, OHIOSeneca Dam RoadPark RoadLashley RoadWintergreen RoadOpossum Run RoadSenecaville DamMarina PointCampgroundMarinaThe Dockside,seasonalParksideCampgroundBeachExit 37About 2 milesHigh Street Seneca00.51 mi
31328557431356614728577SENECAVILLEPLEASANTCITYSENECA LAKE, OHIOSeneca Dam RoadPark RoadClay Pike RoadLashley RoadWintergreen RoadSeneca Fork Wills CreekSenecaville DamMarina PointCampgroundMarinaThe Dockside, seasonalParkside CampgroundBeachExit 37About 2 milesHigh Street Seneca012 mi
★ High Street Seneca, 166 South High Street · About 2 miles by road to Seneca Lake Park at its Marina Point entrance · Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors
  • High Street Seneca, 166 South High Street, Senecaville
  • Seneca Lake Park, about 2 miles east by road: SR 313 to the Marina Point entrance
  • Senecaville Dam, on SR 574 (Seneca Dam Road)
  • Marina, with The Dockside, seasonal
  • Marina Point Campground
  • Parkside Campground, on Park Road off SR 574
  • Beach
  • I-77 Exit 37, west on SR 313
3,550acres of water
499campsites
114cabins
Year roundpark is open

Park figures from mwcd.org.

Call ahead Directions to the store

Hours and directions

Open seven days

Sunday8am to 7pm
Monday7am to 7pm
Tuesday7am to 7pm
Wednesday7am to 7pm
Thursday7am to 7pm
Friday7am to 8pm
Saturday7am to 8pm

Holiday hours can differ. Call ahead on a holiday.

Find us

166 S High St
Senecaville, OH 43780

285313285High Street Seneca166 South High StreetSenecaville Post OfficeSenecaville UnitedMethodist ChurchSecrest ElementarySchoolSenecavilleCemeterySeneca Lake ParkAbout 2 milesSR 313 east to Marina Pointto I-77 Exit 37SENECAVILLENorth High StreetClay Pike RoadWintergreen RoadBridge StreetRichland StreetChurch Street05001,000 ft
★ High Street Seneca, 166 South High Street, Senecaville · Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors
Get directionsSave our number

Look for this

The High Street Seneca building from the street

Questions people ask

Is this the old Seneca Deli Stop?
Yes. Same building on South High Street, same phone number. New owners took over in the summer of 2025 and the store trades as High Street Seneca now.
Do you make subs to order?
Yes. The Seneca Subs counter inside the store makes subs and sandwiches to order. Call (740) 685-5954 to ask what is on today.
How far is the store from Seneca Lake?
About two miles. The store is on South High Street in Senecaville, roughly two miles west of Seneca Lake Park.
Are you open on Sundays?
Yes, seven days a week. Sunday is 8am to 7pm. Monday to Thursday is 7am to 7pm and Friday and Saturday is 7am to 8pm.
Do you do party trays?
Call the store at (740) 685-5954 to ask about trays, what goes on them, the sizes and how much notice is needed.
Where can I see the menu and prices?
The full list is going up on this page shortly. Until then, call the store and the counter will tell you what is on today.

Know when the menu lands

Leave your email and we will tell you once the full sub menu and prices are on this page. Nothing else, ever.

Only used to tell you when the menu is up. No lists, no passing it on.

Thanks. We will let you know the moment the menu is up.